I like the foot control because it keeps your hands free all the time. It's easier to use in the long run. It's a little more work to mount them but well worth it. Just make sure you get one with a variable speed and not a 5 speed. You can match the wind or current correctly and the battery can last a little longer.

I personally own a Motor Guide digital series motor with cable steering. I have had it for a year now and it has been flawless.