Pete,

Jeremy has been painting up some custom colors for shows and other special events. These have a more durable finish than the factory runs. I didn't see the sale post yet, but I'm assuming this is from Black Dog's site where they're selling the blemished baits?

The blemished baits are from the factory run so will not have as durable finish as the ones that Jeremy paints himself.

Having said all that, i fish mine straight out of the package and haven't had a problem yet, but I've heard from others who have had a different experience than myself.