Well you might be out of luck. Flutter craft went out of business years ago. You might be able to find a few select colors laying around, but guys in the know I can put money down have bought up all the GOOD colors. My buddy just got rid of the last of his stock as he was the one that bought out Flutter Craft and he had all the good colors. I got a ton but trust me will not sell any of them. The 4" worm you want is called the "softie". The last tackle shop that I saw them in was Bobs Tackle in Norwalk and he had some OK colors. He was asking $8 for 25pk.