I knew it wasn't you I was just using "you" as an example.

"The customer is always right". Period!

You (not you, hehe) are paying for the trip and can do whatever you want. If anyone gives you a hard time don't tip them or warn them that any grief they give you for CnR will come out of their tip. Then let them know that you will keep an accurate count and let them know what it was at the end of the trip.

What gets me is that they not only try and encourage people to keep all the fish but they actually try and encourage people to break the law and have the more successful fishermen fill the less successful fishermen's limits - that's just plain wrong.