Well, let me just say that they both are a royal pain in the a@@ to get to run straight right out of the package. I'd have to give the edge to the Osprey though. The Eagle is a tad too heavy and bulky. Also, the colors could use some help. When you find a perfect Osprey, handle it with care because who knows how long it will be before you find another one that's as good. In all reality, they are the same bait. Eagle copied the Osprey and made a few changes to it.